November, 2009 Review of The Lexicographer's Dilemma Date : 11-03 19:51: Views: 932 Comments : 0 Topic :Books gpullman@gsu.edu |
"Correct" English, as Lynch characterizes it, is basically "the English wealthy and powerful people spoke a generation or two ago." And sure enough, the first guides to English usage promised to teach people to write and speak with greater "elegance" and "politeness," not greater correctness. These manuals, born of an age of increased social mobility, were intended for "a newly self-conscious group of people who were no longer peasants but still were excluded from the traditional aristocracy." The suddenly rich children of merchants and manufacturers needed instructions on the elegant grammar (and manners) of the aristocracy in order to blend in with their social superiors. Tellingly, the 300-year history of fulmination against improper usage is marked by diatribes against those "inferior" and upstart groups supposedly most prone to transgression: women, young people, racial and ethnic minorities and, of course, Americans. (link) | Input
AdminAdd Email updates Links
Aldaily Blogrunner Books24/7 Digg Gizmodo Google News Inform Internet news LifeHacker News Now UK News Wire Overheard NYC rhetcomp Sifry's Alerts Web Dev Hndbk Webcreme Topics 8123 (47)adult literacy (20) Aphorisms (6) Blogging (81) Blogging & Teaching (3) Blogging History (0) Blogging Software (16) Books (34) CMS (5) commonplaces (22) Composition (9) critical thinking (3) CSS (33) CTW (3) DTP (2) E-texts (1) Epolitics (2) Home Repair (1) InfoVis (2) Java (0) Javascript (3) misc (29) MySQL (1) news (1) Open source (3) PHP (35) PR (2) QEP (3) rhetoric (39) Robotic grading (6) RSS (6) Social Software (2) Software (9) Teaching (15) Usability (2) Writing (41) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||